Winning formula Drive to turn reform into growth and jobs Whether it applies to job hunting or running the Comrades, you need a plan. You need to know what you are aiming for, how to get there and how to measure progress. And then you need the drive and skills to execute. SA has had many economic growth plans, and businesses have good reason to judge them by what they deliver rather than what they promise. The third phase of the Government-Business Partnership, launched on 20 August, aims to turn progress on reform into faster growth and job creation. The first two phases did deliver, helping to end load shedding and improve rail and port performance, alongside other structural reforms. Phase 3 focuses on mining, tourism, infrastructure and agriculture, with the aim of lifting growth above 3% and creating 1 million more jobs by 2030. Achieving that will require businesses to invest – both money and commitment. The partnership recognises that this depends in part on giving businesses a reason to believe that better conditions will last, and that investing in SA will pay off. A new factory, mine or hotel requires a substantial commitment of capital, often over many years, and the returns are uncertain. Even when conditions start to improve, a business might wait for more evidence before committing. If enough businesses hesitate, investment remains weak, the economy adds capacity too slowly and growth disappoints. That leaves fewer opportunities to create the jobs the country needs. Investment decisions are not made on spreadsheets alone. John Maynard Keynes described the impulse to invest, or not, as ‘animal spirits’: the willingness to act in the face of uncertainty. Businesses commit capital not only because the numbers work, but because they believe conditions will remain favourable long enough to generate a return. SA has given investors plenty of reasons to pause. Transnet’s rail concessioning started, stopped and started again. Changes to land-expropriation laws raised doubts about property rights, even where the law was misread. Long-proposed health insurance reforms raise questions about future cost. Uncertainty doesn’t always originate at home, either. Earlier this year, an energy shock beyond SA’s control pushed the North-West University Business School’s Policy Uncertainty Index to a record high. Uncertainty has an economic cost. When the outlook is unclear, projects are postponed, hiring plans are put on hold, and capital stays on the sidelines. Nicholas Bloom’s 2009 paper, Impact of Uncertainty Shocks, simply quantified what most executives know from experience. Gross fixed capital formation is running at about 13.7% of GDP – less than half the National Development Plan’s 30% target for 2030. Confidence alone will not close that gap. Reforms must improve the prospects for investment and give businesses reason to believe those improvements will last. That’s why the partnership’s emphasis on credibility matters. Confidence cannot be a line item in an action plan. It must be earned through delivery. Reliable electricity, trains that run and predictable regulation build credibility. Credibility builds confidence, and confidence encourages investment. This is the flywheel that SA needs. There are signs of progress, but the data shows that businesses are not yet convinced. Business confidence reached 47 in the first quarter, its highest level in almost five years, before falling to 38 in the third. Fifty marks the neutral line on the index. The economy shrank 0.2% in the second quarter, ending six quarters of growth, while gross fixed capital formation remains weak. These figures are not a verdict on Phase 3, which has barely begun. But they underline the urgency. About 300 000 new work-seekers enter the labour force each year. The test is whether reform can prompt businesses to invest, expand and create jobs on a scale that makes a difference. The partnership has promised detailed delivery plans and metrics in the fourth quarter, with public reporting on progress and challenges. We need to see what is changing in practice. Are constraints being removed? Are commitments being met? Is investment responding? Reporting setbacks as well as gains will give businesses and consumers a clearer basis for judging improvements. Hope is not a plan. Confidence is not a slogan. The success of Phase 3 will be measured by businesses committing capital, creating jobs and betting on SA. By Sasha Planting