Sustainable objectives SMEs need skills, support and regulatory frameworks to participate fully in SA’s growing green economy Small businesses drive SA’s economy, so it stands to reason that small businesses will drive the green economy. Right? Well, maybe not. It’s true that formal small businesses contributed 19% of GDP and 33% of employment in 2023, while the informal sector added just under 5% of GDP and 17% of employment (according to data from Trade & Industrial Policy Strategies). So yes, SMEs do drive a large part of the economy. But while small enterprises punch above their weight in the broader economy, they are underperforming in the green economy, lagging in skills development, market participation and funding. Maxwell Gomera, resident representative of the United Nations Development Programme in SA and director of the Africa Sustainable Finance Hub, highlighted the skills gap at Africa’s Green Economy Summit (AGES), which took place in Cape Town in February. ‘The demand for green talent is growing twice as fast as the supply,’ he said, adding that while Africa’s green economy could generate more than 3 million direct jobs, 60% of those would require skilled workers. ‘We are building an engine with no one trained to run it,’ he said. ‘We can borrow capital, but we cannot continue to import capability, and we cannot outsource responsibility.’ Speakers at the summit agreed that, in most economies, small enterprises carry much of the burden of skills development. The consensus – both on stage and on the floor – was that many of the green skills (green-skilled people) that are needed to grow the green economy will have to come from green SMEs. And there’s the catch. Despite the opportunity, most unlisted SMEs are not yet taking the gap to offer environmentally responsible products and services, because there’s no real incentive to do so. Speaking after the AGES event, Carl Reynolds, founder and CEO of ESG assessment and advisory firm Kudos One, pointed to the vast capability and resources around ESG availability in the listed sector. ‘If you’re a listed entity, you have regulatory requirements to do it and a number of other requirements to report on your ESG or sustainability activities, and there’s a massive industry of support around that,’ he said. ‘However, SMEs don’t have regulatory requirements to comply with ESG standards. They have very little pressure externally, and they have almost zero capability or interest if they’re running small businesses. If you add in a new layer of responsibility and cost to that business, it’s a non-starter.’ Reynolds argued that if SMEs see no need to become more sustainable or ESG-aware, there is ‘absolutely no chance of achieving any of our societal goals’, such as the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) or the Paris Climate Accord. ‘None of those things are even remotely possible unless we mobilise the SME community towards more responsible business,’ he said. ‘And that’s a very real risk.’ It’s also a missed opportunity. SA’s green economy is growing fast, spurred by green finance and blended-capital-backed sectors. Priority is being given to enterprises aligned with the Just Energy Transition – including renewable energy, energy efficiency, sustainable agriculture and circular economy initiatives – particularly in coal regions such as Mpumalanga. Solar installation, small-scale wind and energy-efficiency consulting for commercial buildings are all growing as rising Eskom tariffs push demand for alternatives. Research by FSD Africa estimates the green economy will generate between 85 000 and 275 000 new green jobs in SA alone by 2030, mainly in energy and power production, as well as in agriculture and nature. So what’s standing in the way of SA’s green SMEs? Obert Matarirano, associate professor in the Department of Business Management and Economics at Walter Sisulu University, and Trust Chireka, associate professor and head of accounting in the Department of Accounting, Economics and Finance at the University of Fort Hare, sought to find out. Their research found that SMEs are most likely to adopt sustainable practices if they are aware of green finance, want to adapt to climate change and believe in sustainability. ‘One of our most important findings is that awareness strongly influences whether SMEs adopt sustainability practices,’ they write in the Conversation. ‘Being aware of climate change doesn’t automatically translate into adopting sustainability practices because of costs and other factors. However, SMEs that are aware of sustainability practices are more likely to adopt them. SMEs that understand that introducing sustainability measures can reduce business costs over time are more likely to go green.’ However, their research also found that – despite the push from environmental activists and the pull from green investors – many SMEs are not taking up environmentally friendly measures. The reason? ‘SMEs lack clear, reliable information on sustainability,’ Matarirano and Chireka write. ‘It’s often assumed that difficulty in getting green finance is the biggest reason SMEs aren’t environmentally friendly. Our findings, however, reveal an interesting and somewhat unexpected result. In some cases, SMEs may be aware of green finance opportunities but still unable to start sustainable projects. This can happen because they lack the technical capacity, operational systems or institutional support needed. In other words, funding alone is not enough. Businesses also need practical support.’ Reynolds agrees. Through the Kudos Foundation, he founded 1 000 SMEs NPC, an industry-led initiative to drive the development of sustainable or responsible small businesses. The 1 000 small businesses in question are accessed through the supply chains of corporate partners such as Old Mutual, Hollard and SA Breweries. Through its work, the 1 000 SMEs initiative reached the same conclusion as Matarirano and Chireka: many small businesses want to participate in the green economy, but don’t know where or how. ‘In the Old Mutual supply chain, for example, we identified that up to 84% of their SMEs in their supply chain were really keen to have an ESG strategy – or at least a direction to go in as far as ESG is concerned,’ Reynolds said. ‘Less than 30% of them had any interaction, whether it was a policy, a board mandate or anything like that to do with ESG. That means that there’s at least a 50% aspirational gap among these companies who really want to engage but have no idea where to start. There are no frameworks, no resources or anything like that.’ However, Old Mutual, being regulated by the JSE, has a very clear mandate to bring sustainability into its supply chain. ‘They suddenly have an opportunity here to address what has been identified as a very real opportunity in their supply chain, to help these companies achieve something that they’ve said they want to,’ said Reynolds. And those small companies do want to… But SA’s green transition will only accelerate when small businesses see sustainability not as an abstract ideal, but as a practical pathway to competitiveness, resilience and growth. Closing the awareness and capability gap is now the decisive step. SMEs need clear frameworks, accessible support and strong market signals to turn intention into action. If those pieces fall into place, the country’s small business backbone can become the engine of a greener, more inclusive economy – one that creates the jobs, innovation and local impact the green transition depends on. By Mark Van Dijk Image: iStock