Next in line A considered, transparent succession plan is vital to a company’s sustainability The past few years have produced an unusually rich crop of global corporate leadership transitions: some meticulously engineered, others improvised in real time, but all highlighting the critical importance of a robust succession strategy. Consider AIG. In July 2025, the insurer recruited John Neal, respected former chief of Lloyd’s of London, to step into CEO Peter Zaffino’s shoes – only to be blindsided when Neal became embroiled in controversy relating to an inappropriate relationship at his former workplace. AIG terminated the appointment and paid him $2.7 million to compensate for the pay he’d forfeited elsewhere, a costly sum for a hire who never performed the role. The board improvised and selected Eric Andersen in early 2026 as interim CEO, causing the Financial Times to describe its succession process as ‘rocky’, a sentiment reflected in consecutive stock price falls. Then there’s Fermi, the AI-focused data centre developer, which lost its CEO and CFO abruptly in April. The company put interim leadership arrangements in place and began a formal search for a permanent CEO, but the sudden departures highlighted the absence of a clearly identified successor, and stock fell more than 17%. And there’s Workday, where co-founder Aneel Bhusri had to climb back into the CEO’s chair after Carl Eschenbach’s unexpected exit, which led to a 6% stock decline. Morgan Stanley’s handling of its own transition is instructive by comparison. CEO James Gorman reportedly presented the board with a succession plan three weeks into his 13-year tenure. In May 2023, he announced his intention to step down in 12 months, and the board developed three internal candidates, a plan that allowed the board to observe – and test – their suitability over that time. The final choice, Ted Pick, was a co-president and three-decade veteran of the firm, and has since overseen strong growth, with revenue rising 14% to a record $70.6 billion in 2025. In SA, Dis-Chem is a ‘strong recent example of succession done properly’, says Debbie Goodman, CEO of executive recruitment agency Jack Hammer Executive Search. ‘The timeline tells much of the story on its own. Rui Morais was first identified as Ivan Saltzman’s successor in 2021 and only took up the CEO role two years later, which gave the business a considerable runway rather than forcing a last-minute scramble. Saltzman remained involved through that transition period, which allowed the market time to build confidence in Morais well before he assumed full control of the business.’ According to research published in the Harvard Business Review, large companies’ failure to pay enough attention to their leadership pipelines and succession practices leads to excessive turnover at the top and destroys a significant amount of value – close to $1 trillion a year among the S&P 1500 alone. The authors found that large companies’ excessive tendency to hire leaders from outside is one of the biggest problems with succession practices. ‘This propensity incurs three major kinds of costs: the underperformance at companies who hire ill-suited external CEOs, the loss of intellectual capital in the C-suites of the organisations that executives leave behind, and for those companies promoting from within, the lower performance of ill-prepared successors.’ In Goodman’s view, one of the most common mistakes firms make is treating succession planning as something you do once and then file away, when in reality the business, the market and the pool of viable candidates are all moving constantly. ‘A succession plan that isn’t revisited regularly is often out of date long before anyone notices. Another mistake I see often is boards gravitating towards a successor who closely resembles the outgoing CEO, rather than asking what the business actually needs at its next stage of growth – since what got a company to where it is now rarely happens to be what gets it to where it needs to go next. There’s also a tendency for boards to run the entire process too privately, which means that when a successor is finally named, it can feel like a surprise to the wider executive team rather than the natural outcome of a process people had visibility into. A lack of transparency can erode trust at precisely the moment the organisation needs it most.’ To fully grasp the stakes, it’s useful to look more closely at the anatomy of the CEO role itself, and how instability or a gap at the top can ripple through everything from strategy and investor confidence to employee morale and business performance. Owen Skae, director of Rhodes Business School, says the CEO occupies a critical position between the board and the executive team. While the board is ultimately responsible for the company’s strategy, business model and long-term value creation, the CEO is charged with turning that strategy into action, providing a critical link between management and the governing body. ‘Without a solid, proactive CEO succession strategy, a company faces a critical leadership and operational vacuum,’ he says. ‘The most immediate danger is that there is no leader to ensure the implementation and execution of the company’s strategy as envisaged. This failure manifests as strategic drift, operational friction and a breakdown in the delegation of authority, which can severely compromise the organisation’s status as a going concern.’ Under the King V Code on Corporate Governance (the latest update to SA’s corporate governance framework, released in 2025), the governing body is explicitly required to oversee that robust succession planning is continuously in place for the CEO position to safeguard leadership continuity and organisational stability, he says. ‘This responsibility is typically delegated to the committee responsible for nomination governance, which must maintain a long-term, active succession plan for the board, its committees and critical executive positions.’ Boards must ask themselves the difficult, uncomfortable questions, most notably: what happens if our CEO is hit by a bus tomorrow? Skae says this requires a dual-track strategy: emergency contingency planning, in other words, having an immediate, pre-identified interim leader who can step in instantly to maintain stability, protect operations and reassure stakeholders; and long-term pipeline development, a continuous process of identifying, mentoring and developing internal talent over a multi-year horizon so that there is always a natural, prepared cohort of potential successors. Most reputable business schools already place succession planning firmly on the corporate governance agenda, reflecting the fact that future leaders need to understand not just how to lead a business, but how to ensure continuity when they leave. ‘At Rhodes Business School, we address these critical leadership pipeline and transition challenges through a multi-disciplinary approach across three core modules: ethical organisation and governance, responsible leadership and people management,’ says Skae. ‘We focus on the board’s role as the focal point of governance, its ultimate accountability for succession planning and the mechanics of combined assurance. We prepare future executives to understand that sustainable value creation requires balancing the interests of the business, society and the ecological systems they operate in, fostering a service-oriented mindset over a self-serving one. And we cover the practical, human side of talent management, including structured mentoring, performance evaluation and building a robust internal talent pipeline.’ Goodman says the boards most likely to get it right are the ones that start succession planning from day one, as a standing item on the agenda rather than a project that only gets switched on once a CEO announces they’re leaving. ‘In practice, that means three to five years is a realistic window for properly identifying and developing internal candidates before a transition is needed. For founder-led businesses in particular, I’d push that timeline even earlier, because the handover there is as much an emotional and cultural process as it is an operational one.’ The test she encourages any board to apply isn’t whether they technically have a plan sitting in a folder somewhere, but whether they could credibly name an interim CEO tomorrow morning if circumstances forced their hand – bringing us back to Skae’s run-over-by-a-bus analogy. ‘If your top three executives each received a call from a headhunter tomorrow, how many of them do you think would actually take that call? If the honest answer is more than one, that tells you something important about the strength, or fragility, of your pipeline,’ says Goodman. ‘A genuinely strong succession pipeline means having multiple credible internal candidates ready for every critical role in the business, not just the CEO seat, and it requires the board to actually know these people well enough to have a sense of how they think and operate under real pressure, rather than relying on what looks good on paper. It also means the organisation is investing in developing that talent on an ongoing basis, rather than only turning its attention to succession once a vacancy has already opened up.’ By Robyn Maclarty Image: iStock