Customer care

Companies’ judicious and careful use of AI can enhance their marketing and user experience

Customer care

Apple’s iconic ‘Think different’ slogan, launched in 1997, was conceived by a core group of people at an advertising agency and helped lift the company out of a financial crisis. The campaign transformed the customer experience from transactional, where they were simply buying a product, to an emotional one where they felt part of an exclusive group. It ran for five years and cost a reported $90 million.

The marketing and customer experience (CX) has changed drastically since then. In fact, it’s pretty much been turned on its head by artificial intelligence (AI). The digital revolution has fundamentally changed how businesses engage and interact with customers, with AI now one of its most influential forces. While traditional marketing uses tools such as billboards and broadcast media to reach their audience, the new buzzwords now include automation, chatbots and algorithms.

The Digital School of Marketing says the AI roll-out in SA has also meant small and medium-sized enterprises are examining the potential of AI-based platforms to improve their competitiveness without hiring new staff. This increased availability is driving the adoption of AI throughout the industry.

Former FNB CEO Michael Jordaan firmly believes in AI’s ability to enhance marketing productivity with much smaller teams. ‘Size comes with time,’ he says. ‘It’s more important to focus on solving a specific problem, because once that is achieved, growth comes naturally.’ Jordaan has consistently backed technology-driven solutions to market inefficiencies, prioritising companies that solve specific problems over those chasing scale. His firm, Montegray Capital, recently announced another investment – in the SA start-up Adbot, which builds automation tools for marketers who need to deliver enterprise-level campaigns but don’t have the resources to do so.

In 2023, Jordaan, also the chairman and co-founder of Bank Zero, told the Money Show with Bruce Whitfield that he thought ‘businesses that don’t lean into AI, those that don’t start using it for decision-making, may not be around in five to 10 years. No use fighting this macro trend. Rather lean in’.

Which is exactly what SA businesses have had to do when it comes to brand awareness and customer relationships.

Thakane Setsabi-Mushonga, the general manager of customer solutions at Old Mutual, says that ‘to remain relevant and to keep improving our customer experience, we are driven to keep enhancing the services we provide to our customers’. She adds that the impact of AI can be seen most clearly in how Old Mutual serves customers every day. Service and inquiry bots, for example, reduce holding times and allow customers to self-direct their journeys to more convenient times, and AI-driven automation of high-volume processes has resulted in faster turnaround times and lower costs.

Claims and disbursements that previously took days to process can now, based on set criteria, be paid out within minutes. This responsiveness not only saves customers valuable time but also enhances trust and belief in the brand. ‘Through AI, we achieve economies of scale that allow us to offer more value to customers while simultaneously improving their experience,’ says Setsabi-Mushonga. As the insurance and financial giant looks to the future, she says Old Mutual believes AI will ‘continue to open new possibilities to enhance service quality’.

Enrico Ferigolli, omnichannel retail executive at Pick n Pay, tells ITWeb that AI is also having an impact on how consumers shop. ‘While on-demand delivery transformed how South Africans buy groceries, AI is now changing how they order,’ he says, describing conversational AI as ‘the next major shift in online retail’. He explains how SA’s first conversational AI grocery shopping assistant, Penny, integrated directly into the Pick n Pay app and powered by Google’s Gemini AI models, allows shoppers to build baskets, plan meals and request product swaps using voice notes, text or photos. He adds that multilingual capabilities – particularly for SA’s African languages – are still improving, although voice support is more advanced than text. He believes that consumers ‘no longer just want speed; they want shopping apps to think for them’.

However, consumers also don’t want their experiences to lose the human touch completely. While AI may save time, improve decision-making and make products more accessible to customers, people still value human interaction.

AI may be useful for answers to uncomplicated queries, but it can be hugely frustrating when customers trying to solve a more complex issue are forced to type keyword after keyword into a chatbot.

A new report by marketing insight consultancy Human8 shows that South Africans are increasingly concerned that this element could be lost as AI continues to evolve. The 2026 What Matters trend report reveals that while 63% of SA respondents to the survey say AI positively affects their daily lives, 62% worry the human touch will be lost, and 56% are concerned about its broader societal impact.

The issue goes beyond whether customers prefer speaking to a human, however. It also raises questions about transparency and trust. Michele van Eck, associate professor in the School of Law at Wits University, cautions that when companies don’t disclose when customers are speaking to a machine, not a person, it has a major impact on their experience, and leads businesses into murky ethical and legal waters. She recalls phoning her insurer recently and realising midway through the conversation that she wasn’t speaking to a person.

‘What unsettled me most was not that the company used artificial intelligence. It was that nobody had told me. There was no disclosure at the beginning of the call. No indication that I was interacting with a machine. No obvious option to request a human representative. Had I not been paying close attention, I may never have realised it.’

Van Eck adds that speaking to a human being or a machine is material. ‘It affects how you communicate, what you disclose, how much trust you place in the interaction and whether you choose to escalate a matter to a person.

‘There is also a deeper concern,’ she says. ‘Many companies appear to be designing AI voice agents to sound indistinguishable from humans. After all, if customers realise too quickly that they are speaking to a machine, many may immediately ask for a human agent, which may, in turn, affect the cost savings and efficiencies in using the AI voice agent in the first place. The commercial incentive is therefore not merely automation, but seemingly also concealed automation.’

Van Eck adds that while SA law doesn’t prohibit the use of undisclosed AI voice agents, existing legal frameworks, including the Consumer Protection Act, ‘strongly suggest that companies should not be deploying these systems deceptively’.

Jordaan predicted a few years ago that AI would become ‘ubiquitous, indispensable and powerful across our modern world’. And that has indeed proved to be the case. However, the increased presence and use of AI brings with it an increase in issues for businesses to consider when it comes to providing a satisfying experience for customers. As Setsabi-Mushonga says, ‘the future of customer experience lies in the balance of intelligent technology and human care, working together to deliver the service our customers deserve’.

By Philippa Byron
Image: iStock