DRIVING PROGRESS

MSCT BEE Services explains why purposeful transformation strategies can deliver stronger economic outcomes and lasting societal value

BEE legislation has been in the public spotlight, with many questions being raised about the impact of the legislation over the past 23 years. Many question the true objectives of the legislative framework, with repeated complaints and claims that only a few have benefited from the implementation of BEE.

It is true that there are many areas of concern in terms of the governance surrounding the legislation and the code of ethics that advisers, consultants and rating agencies should follow when determining the outcome and status of transformation compliance. Unfortunately, the emphasis has been misplaced in the application of the legislation, focusing merely on tick-box compliance and relying on systems that simply state ‘yes’ or ‘no’. There are individuals administering a transformation strategy centred on simple compliance and points rather than purpose, time and the impact on the identified beneficiaries.

There is also a common misconception that engaging with competent BEE specialists – those who understand and execute the true intent of the legislation – will result in a process that is overly complicated and time consuming. This is especially pertinent in cases where entities will rather take a chance on interpretive compliance with a perceived outlook that the process is simpler, faster and may produce a better result or score.

There are no shortcuts – not in life and not in BEE. When a strategy of compliance is administered with the intent to facilitate and meet the objectives, the process becomes simpler, more cost effective and yields higher impact results. A higher status of true compliance in turn inspires confidence in the entity’s business dealings.

Stanley Grau, Managing Director, MSCT BEE Services

While there are many benefits for the measured entity in achieving a compliance status, the true intent of the legislation should always be front and centre of the strategy.

BEYOND TICK-BOX THINKING

Transformation is an important part of SA’s legislation, designed with the objective to improve the economic status of the country and its people. Economic transformation means economic change. It is not simply a case of black and white. Let’s delve into some statistics to map out a story.

In 2003, the SA population was estimated at 46 million people, with a demographic split –as per the definition contained in the BEE legislative framework – estimated at 89% black people and 11% white people.

In 2026, the estimated population stands at 64 million, with a demographic split of approximately 91% black and 9% white people. This is an estimated 39% increase in the SA population over the past 23 years.

Stats SA also recently released data showcasing there has been an increase in household income. Compared to the statistics of 2001, the 2023 data reflects an estimated 4% increase in the black African demographic, an estimated 3% increase in the coloured demographic, an estimated 0.1% increase in the Indian/Asian demographic, and an estimated decrease of 7% in the white demographic.

These stats are compared from the 2023 statistical data versus the 2001 statistical data as a percentage of the total household income reported on by Stats SA. Though the net result still shows a high percentage of income inequality between the demographic bands as a percentage of income per household versus the relevant demographic population, there has been economic improvement.

This must all be understood in context of the broader economic transformation objectives. The key question is not whether household income grew because inflation makes the above comparison meaningless. Rather, what matters is whether there has been a real increase in income per person, employment opportunities and productive economic capacity to support an additional 18 million people.

Based on the statistical formula of employment access, labour absorption, unemployment and if there is a growth in employment relative to the working-age population, the net result is estimated to be 5.6% worse per person.

Many factors influence these results, including global economic challenges that have impacted the SA population and business. However, the more concerning measure is the absorption rate, which is the percentage of the working-age population versus those who are securing employment. The estimated result is also at -1.5% per person.

Between 2013 and 2026, the estimated working-age population grew by 26.9%, but the employment population only grew by 22%, while the unemployed population grew by almost 80%. For black South Africans, specifically, the estimated working population grew by 33% and employment grew by approximately 31%, but unemployment increased by around 91%.

So, while an estimated 3 million additional black SA people have been employed, the number of people seeking or requiring employment has increased even faster.

MSCT BEE Services places purpose at the heart of BEE

BEE is not about demographics; it’s about identifying the economic areas that require change, how to remedy them and, in turn, improving our own economic standards and the environment around us.

SHARED RESPONSIBILITY

South Africans have chosen to live here and to celebrate its victories – and challenges – as a nation of people. With this comes the responsibility to help improve the nation and to leave its environment in a better condition than it was when we entered it.

Partnerships between competent and knowledgeable people to work on solutions that drive positive change are crucial to the impact the transformation agenda can deliver.

‘I call on entities that make up these partnerships and contributions to do your due diligence on what the true impact of the strategy will be or, at the very least, the economic change that can potentially be made in a person’s environment and day-to-day life,’ says Stanley Grau, MD of MSCT BEE Services.

‘The statistics show where support is needed. Let’s focus on these areas and work towards creating a more sustainable place that benefits all.’


+27 (0)21 852 5646
[email protected]
www.msctbee.co.za