Renewed friendship

The warm diplomatic relationship between SA and Indonesia has the potential to spur more business ties

Renewed friendship

Indonesia was a key founding member of the Non-Aligned Movement (NAM), which was launched at the Bandung Conference in 1955. The movement, which still has a low-profile existence among nations of the Global South, was a resolute opponent of apartheid and a supporter of the ANC in exile. Two members of the ANC in fact attended the founding conference.

Bandung, located on Java, the most populous of the south-east Asian archipelago nation’s 17 000 islands, was also the site of SA’s first official post-apartheid initiative in the region. An Asian-African conference was held at that venue in 2003, followed by a return event in Durban the following year. These events led to the establishment of the New Asian-African Strategic Partnership in 2005 with SA and Indonesia as co-chairs.

The two governments have repeatedly referred to their friendship and alignment within the G20, chaired by SA last year, and BRICS+, which Indonesia joined in 2025. There have been 17 memoranda of understanding (MoUs) between the two countries since 1997, covering most economic sectors. The most recent was a tourism MoU, signed earlier this year. However, tourism is something of a one-way trade with nearly 30 000 South Africans visiting Indonesia in 2025 but only 3 000 Indonesians making the return journey.

While the strength of diplomatic ties cannot be doubted, turning this into viable commercial relationships has proven more elusive. The progress of the Joint Commission for Bilateral Co-operation, established in 2005, is revealing. It met only twice in the next 13 years and can be regarded as moribund. The parallel Joint Trade Committee was even less effective.

One of the purposes of President Cyril Ramaphosa’s first official visit to Indonesia in 2025 was to revive commercial relations between the two countries. Speaking in the Indonesian capital, Jakarta, last October, he referred to ‘the strong business delegation’ that had accompanied him ‘with a view to building new commercial partnerships between our countries’.

Ramaphosa said ‘the state visit was preceded by a business forum, which provided a platform for South African companies to engage with their Indonesian counterparts’. He added that ‘one of the key goals of the business forum was to find meaningful ways for our two countries to develop pathways to boost economic growth through business-to-business partnerships’.

At the same event, Ramaphosa’s Indonesian counterpart, President Prabowo Subianto, highlighted the political and historical links between the two countries. ‘We followed your fight, and we admire your strength and perseverance in fighting for freedom and democracy. We wish to strengthen our relations and co-operation that have been established. We are both major countries from the Global South.’

However, there are a number of hurdles to business capitalising on this diplomatic friendship between the two countries. One is sheer distance. SA and Indonesia are 8 500 km apart, and there are no direct connecting flights. More problematic, though, is that the two countries have very similar trade profiles. Both are predominantly commodity exporters. Indonesia is the world’s biggest exporter of nickel and thermal coal, and it accounts for more than half the planet’s palm oil exports.

Indonesia’s main exports to SA are palm oil, cocoa butter, refined petroleum and leather products. In the opposite direction, SA exports ferroalloys, chromium ore, fuel wood, soya beans and raw aluminium to Indonesia. The value of bilateral trade is about $2 billion, less than 4% of the value of SA’s trade with China.

There are, of course, potential areas of technology-based co-operation between the two countries. Both produce future-facing critical minerals, and speaking at last year’s Business Forum, SA’s Deputy Minister of International Relations and Co-operation, Alwin Botes, singled out battery and fuel-cell technologies and the sustainable electric-mobility value chain as possible areas of co-operation. ‘We invite Indonesian firms to explore opportunities in these sectors, including joint ventures, localisation initiatives and knowledge exchange,’ he said.

This sort of co-operation has, however, been slow to get off the ground. New energy firm Pertamina signed an agreement with SA’s Guma Energy for the development of a 1.6 GW gas-fired power plant in 2024. But earlier this year, the Indonesian partner complained that it was still waiting for ‘further clarity’ from its SA partner.

Rather than industrial co-operation, the most viable future relationships may follow the pattern pioneered by SA asset manager Allan Gray earlier this year. Taking advantage of a sharp (35%) downward movement of the Jakarta Stock Exchange in January, Allan Gray seized the moment and purchased a portion of Indofood Sukses Makmur, one of the world’s largest makers of instant noodles.

‘We’ve been looking at Indonesia for some time,’ says Rory Kutisker-Jacobson, a portfolio manager at Allan Gray’s Frontier Markets Equity Fund. Kutisker-Jacobson describes the fund, with assets of nearly $1.5 billion, as ‘tending towards being contrarian in nature’. Indonesia is one of more than 20 frontier and emerging markets that it follows.

Allan Gray had been following between 20 and 30 listed Indonesian companies. When the market threw up a buying opportunity after MSCI (previously Morgan Stanley Capital Investments), which maintains an emerging market index, warned that it could downgrade Indonesia due to ‘investability concerns’, Allan Gray narrowed its focus.

‘We focused on a basket of eight or nine promising companies and did some more fundamental analysis,’ says Kutisker-Jacobson. ‘Indofoods was the most attractive option. They have 70% of the Indonesian market, are tightly run and treat minority shareholders fairly.’

As MSCI said in January, there are real pitfalls in the Indonesian stock market. Ownership is highly concentrated among a small number of founding or prominent family businesses. Not only does this result in problems such as limited liquidity and related-party transactions, but it is also an obstacle to creative destruction, a necessary aspect of economic growth. This is why the state-owned matchmaking firm, Business Indonesia, described economic prospects for 2026 as ‘resilient’ but noted that ‘acceleration [is] elusive’.

But Indonesia is an attractive potential market. Its population of 290 million makes it the fourth-biggest country in the world. Jakarta, with a population of 42 million, is the world’s biggest city. High GDP growth – more than 5% for the past decade – has seen Indonesia’s middle class grow to about 50 million. Demographically, the country has the same sort of youth potential often singled out as Africa’s comparative advantage – the average age is 30 and many in this age group are notably tech-savvy.

The archipelago nation had been the darling of the emerging markets universe for some years. The spending cap (3% of GDP) imposed after the 1997 Asian financial crisis has ensured fiscal restraint and economic stability. However, according to MSCI, this has been thrown into doubt by the recent policies of Prabowo. The former soldier took office in 2024 with the ambition of turning Indonesia into a high-income nation by 2045, the centenary of its independence. He hopes to raise GDP growth to 8% by 2030.

Prabowo has announced Indonesia would rationalise and sell off 750 notoriously inefficient state-owned enterprises. As part of the process, he has consolidated many of them into the newly created Danantara sovereign wealth fund. He has also launched the Free Nutritious Meals programme, the world’s largest public-feeding scheme, which was initially intended to account for 10% of government expenditure but has since been scaled back. These initiatives, combined with a massive hike in state fuel subsidies, have raised doubts about Indonesia’s fiscal capacity and growth ambitions. There are many parallels between SA and Indonesia. Both have growth ambitions but are finding the process of reform painful. Nevertheless, as Allan Gray has shown, there are excellent private firms and business opportunities in both countries. This suggests that diplomatic closeness could easily be complemented by future commercial engagement.

By David Christianson
Image: iStock