Current account

Although global uncertainties have soared, SA’s listed banking sector has found ways to consolidate and grow

Current account

The PwC Major Banks analysis, published in March, concludes that ‘the results for South Africa’s major banks articulate a coherent story’. That story, it says, is one of ‘a sector that has navigated significant macroeconomic headwinds with discipline, [and] delivered earnings growth that, in several cases, reflects record performance’.

PwC’s Rivaan Roopnarain, a partner in the firm’s banking and capital markets division, notes that this performance has occurred against a ‘backdrop of global volatility’, but also that the sector has benefited from local tailwinds. These include (national) credit rating upgrades, falling inflation (and a new 3% target) and the removal of South Africa from the Financial Action Task Force grey list.

‘The major South African banks have again shown their skill, ability and experience in managing volatility while also creating strong returns in turbulent times,’ says Roopnarain.

Keagan Higgins, an analyst at Anchor Capital, agrees. He argues that ‘the South African banking sector remains in good shape. What I’ve been most impressed by is the level of returns the banks have managed to sustain despite what is still a fairly weak domestic growth environment’.

SA’s listed banks delivered combined headline earnings growth of 9.4% (totalling R152.5 billion) for the 2025 financial year. Combined deposits across the sector reached R8.3 trillion, an increase of 8.4% on 2024. Gross loans and advances reached R6.8 trillion, an increase of 5.8%. These are all record highs for the sector. At the same time, credit loss ratios stabilised or improved across core portfolios throughout the sector.

Part of these glowing figures is the ‘endowment effect’ – analysts’ term for the disproportionate benefits banks reap from higher rates. But in 2025, the endowment benefit in the sector was largely undermined when the South African Reserve Bank began a rate-cutting cycle.

Kevin Hoff, banking sector lead at consultancy BDO, argues that ‘the 2025/26 reporting cycle is a genuine inflection point for the sector’. He argues that ‘the major banks have reduced their reliance on domestic monetary policy and grown their non-interest revenue streams’.

The big beasts on the JSE are Standard Bank and FirstRand Bank, which occupy the top two SA slots in the annual rankings produced by industry publication the Banker. The rankings focus only on Tier 1 Capital, which is a measure of a bank’s core equity and retained earnings and, thus, its ability to absorb sudden shocks. Standard Bank has Tier 1 Capital valued at $16 billion while FirstRand stands at $12.5 billion.

‘Standard Bank has probably been the clearest operational outperformer,’ says Higgins. He notes that ‘it has been remarkably consistent and continues to benefit from both its scale in South Africa and the African franchise it has built over many years’. Standard Bank operates in more than 20 countries in sub-Saharan Africa and makes about 40% of its headline earnings from the continent outside SA.

Standard Bank stands out as the most Africa-exposed in the sector. This has become a positive attribute as many African economies experience much higher growth rates than SA. Angola is expected to grow at 8.7% this year, Ethiopia at 9.8% and Zambia at 7.7%. Higgins argues that ‘Standard Bank is an attractive proposition because it already has a large, established African franchise and is benefiting from investment made over many years’.

Hoff remarks that ‘regional diversification is starting to pay off’. He argues that ‘there is visible differentiation between those [SA banks] that are effectively leveraging their broader African presence and those that are falling behind’. However, the risk premium is high in African markets. Banks talk about ‘the hurdle rate’, which refers to the minimum acceptable return on equity (ROE) for a new investment. The hurdle rate on the continent is typically between five and 15 percentage points higher than developed markets, driven mostly by economic fragilities, inflation and currency fluctuations.

Higgins observes that ‘Africa can be an excellent source of long-term growth, but Absa’s recent experience is also a reminder that it can introduce more earnings volatility’. Absa is the second-most Africa-exposed of the JSE’s banks (with the continent accounting for 28% of its earnings). Absa’s first-half earnings in 2026, released in August, showed a 10% drop in headline earnings from its African operations and, in response, the share price sold off sharply.

‘The issue isn’t really the South African business, which has held up reasonably well. The disappointment was more around Africa regions where lower policy rates compressed margins, together with a softer near-term ROE outlook,’ says Higgins.

There is currently intense competition – featuring three SA banks (Standard, Absa and Nedcor) – in the Kenyan market. Absa is spending $238 million to expand its holding in Absa Bank Kenya (from 68.5 to 85%), and Nedbank is bidding for a controlling stake in NCBA, one of Kenya’s biggest listed lenders. But as strong as the SA banks may be, they do not necessarily have everything their own way. Hoff observes that ‘the competitive threat is not one way: South African lenders are themselves under pressure from rapidly expanding banks in Nigeria and Kenya, particularly in digital financial services’.

Unlike its peers, FirstRand chose not to go heavily into Africa but to place its offshore hedge in the UK. It purchased the Aldmore Group, a motor vehicle finance specialist which included MotoNuvo Finance, for £1.1 billion in 2017. At the time, it presumably saw synergies with its SA WesBank subsidiary. In 2026, however, FirstRand is looking to offload the entire UK operation, noting that ‘the UK operating environment for a consumer finance business is increasingly uncertain’. The issue is regulatory uncertainty surrounding historical motor finance commission arrangements. FirstRand has concluded that ‘further capital deployment would not meet its risk appetite or hurdle rates’.

FirstRand remains a strong performer in SA. ‘This bank is in many respects the quality benchmark in the local market,’ says Higgins. He notes that it has ‘consistently generated strong returns and been particularly disciplined around capital allocation’.

His view is that the UK disposal – with final bids due by the end of 2026 – is important to watch. ‘There are still uncertainties around the timing, structure and valuation of the process. How that plays out has capital implications for FirstRand,’ he says.

Nedbank’s six-month interim results to June 2026 beat its own forecast and market expectations. The counter surged 6% on the announcement. Nedbank had bailed on its 17-year shareholding in Nigeria-based Ecobank, which had become an on-going cash drain on the company. Higgins argues that ‘while the reported earnings numbers were (merely) OK, the underlying performance has been better than those numbers suggest’.

The traditional Big Four banks – Standard, FirstRand, Absa and Nedbank – have been joined by a fifth player in recent years in retail-focused Capitec. Capitec, established in only 2001 with its roots in micro-lending, reached a market capitalisation of R500 billion in 2026, making it the fastest company in SA to achieve this milestone through organic growth. Measured by market capitalisation, Standard, FirstRand and Capitec are of very similar size, with all of them boasting values north of R500 billion. Absa, with a market cap of R194.77 billion and Nedbank (R137.77 billion) round out the major commercial banking institutions on the JSE.

‘Capitec has been the standout structural success story in South African banking’, says Higgins. But it may face challenges holding on to its momentum. ‘The interesting question now is how far Capitec’s model can extend beyond traditional retail banking. Insurance, fintech and business banking are becoming meaningful,’ he says. In Higgins’ view, the challenge for Capitec is to build a much broader financial services business around an enormous customer base.

The sixth counter, Investec (JSE market cap R37.8 billion), is a somewhat different proposition with its focus on specialist banking and wealth management in SA and the UK. With only 128 000 private clients, it doesn’t compete on sheer numbers. But this niche base, which includes at least one-quarter of high-income earners in SA, works for the company. Its dual Johannesburg-London listing offers a built-in currency hedge, and the relative affluence of the company’s client base means that credit loss performance is superior to its peers.

The other counter in the banking segment is Finbond, a small mutual bank with a market cap of about R397 million. This is essentially a microfinance institution probably best known for offering higher fixed interest rates than its competitors. The company owns a US- and Panama-based fintech lender on which it is heavily dependent for profits. The share price has been among the most volatile on the JSE.

Banking in SA is an intensely competitive space, with periodic innovation by disruptors which the incumbents need to respond to. Before the present era, the last major disruption was the emergence of Capitec, which according to Higgins ‘was the original disruptor but can now be regarded as part of the establishment’.

What Capitec forced established banks to do is reassess how they dealt with retail customers, says Higgins. ‘Capitec showed that the economics and customer proposition of banking in South Africa could look very different. It forced the incumbents to rethink fees, branches, digital onboarding and product simplicity.’

The new challenge in 2026 is digital growth and the emergence of smaller, nimble competitors in this space – Discovery Bank, Bank Zero, GoThyme Bank and OM Bank, which launched late last year – with insurance giant Sanlam planning to launch its offering in November and retailer Pepkor in April next year. Roopnarain comments that the most intense competition between established banks in South Africa revolves around digital growth.

‘Mobile-first platforms drive growth. To support this trend, banks are focusing their investment on transitioning and refining core systems,’ says Roopnarain.

While the established banks deal with an ever-evolving technology landscape, the new challengers are swiftly consolidating. At the end of June this year, Discovery Bank surprised the market when it announced its first full-year profit (R370 million).

The future is all about using technology to find synergies between different elements of the financial landscape. ‘Discovery is using the bank as part of a much wider health, insurance and investment proposition,’ says Higgins. ‘The battle increasingly looks to be for more of the customer’s overall financial relationship, rather than just their current account.’

There is no doubt that SA’s banks are well-capitalised, well-managed and well-positioned. Higgins points out that ‘they have shown that they can continue producing attractive returns through a fairly difficult economic backdrop’. The issue from here, he suggests, is ‘which of them can sustain these returns through genuine franchise growth’.

The next competitive cycle has already commenced, and the question is which of SA’s banks will be best at growing customers and advances, building non-interest revenue and controlling costs without taking on more credit risk.

By David Christianson
Image: iStock